MAC Football








MAC Basketball



 

2005 Recruiting Analysis

The 2005 MAC Football Recruiting Analysis has compiled data from dozens of public sources, including regional newspapers that cover MAC schools, several "guru" periodicals and various Internet sources, along with all 12 MAC sports information departments.

Please Note:

  • Most of these kids are anywhere from 17-years to 20-years old so rankings are very subjective - many things can happen to a young man in his college-playing career like injuries, academic problems, personal issues, etc.
  • There are often late bloomers either who rarely show up on the recruiting radar screen and end up becoming all-conference players and sometimes even NFL players. The only way to know how good a class really has been is to look at them after they have graduated in four or five years.
  • I do not have grade transcripts so the only way I have any idea of a potential “prop” recruit is through published sources.  More often than not, I do not take this into consideration unless it is publicized that there are several non-qualifiers.

Due to increased national TV exposure, national ranked teams, Heisman candidates, an ESPN Game Day visit and the general public’s realization that the MAC plays solid football, MAC teams across the board brought in tremendous talent once again this season.  Many players throughout the classes listed below had attractive offers from BCS schools but chose a MAC institution.  Some of the BCS schools that lost players to MAC schools include West Virginia, Indiana, Illinois, Syracuse, Pittsburgh, Northwestern, South Carolina, North Carolina & Iowa State.  Kudos to the coaches and their staffs for putting together such incredible recruiting classes once again this year. 

Within the detail and listings of the recruits on the team’s analysis are the general grades within my usual format of: OUTSTANDING, EXCELLENT, VERY GOOD, GOOD & AVERAGE.

Again, much of this analysis is subjective, so after clicking on your desired MAC team to read and review, post your thoughts on the various Message Boards provided on this site, or send me an Email from the home page. -Nick Gerogosian-

 Click team name for more info

Team

Ranking

Comment

NIU

Outstanding

Without any doubt the best class in the MAC this year.

Akron

Outstanding

JD Brookhart makes tremendous recruiting strides with this class.

WMU

Excellent

New coach, new optimism, terrific crop of newcomers.

Toledo

Excellent

Rockets reload with several promising prospects.

EMU

Excellent

Genyk is getting that "Motown" felling in Ypsi.

CMU

Excellent

Brian Kelly brings in some big guns from Texas.

Miami

Very Good

Small class in numbers, big class in talent.

BGSU

Very Good

Not a lot of stars - just a lot of quality incoming football players.

Ball St

Very Good

Cardinals have Georgia on their mind – along with a ‘southern feel’.

Kent St

Good

Going back to their local recruiting roots provides KSU their best class in years.

Ohio

Good

Solich uncovers gems far and wide to rejuvenate the once proud Bobcats.

Buffalo

Average

UB continues to upgrade their talent across the board.

 

VanDelaySports Recruiting Champs

2005 – NIU

2004 – Toledo

2003 – UCF

2002 – UCF

2001 – Western Michigan

2000 – Marshall

1999 – Marshall

 

 

Top-25 Freshmen

 

 

Top 25 "Sleepers"

1

Dajuane Collins

RB

Toledo

 

1

Tim Conner

RB

Eastern Michigan

2

Antwon Hight

DT

Akron

 

2

Mark Woodson

WR

Kent State

3

Melvin Rice

CB

NIU

 

3

Antonio Brunson

DB/WR

Miami

4

Phil Brown

LB

NIU

 

4

Brian Mellott

DL

Ohio

5

Orlando Moore

WR

NIU

 

5

Brandon Jones

QB

Ohio

6

EJ Morton-Green

WR

Miami

 

6

Chris Jacquemain

QB

Akron

7

Zach Anderson

OL

Akron

 

7

Bobby Thomas

DB/RB

Bowing Green

8

Tim Hiller

QB

Western Michigan

 

8

Eric Heller

LB

Toledo

9

Justin Anderson

RB

NIU

 

9

Brayden Coombs

DB

Miami

10

Sean Price

QB

Central Michigan

 

10

Jacolby Bond

RB

Ball State

11

Brandon Summers

QB

Toledo

 

11

Frank Zombo

TE

Central Michigan

12

Spencer Smith

OLB

Eastern Michigan

 

12

Chris May

DB

Eastern Michigan

13

Terrance Blevins

RB

Eastern Michigan

 

13

Keith Forestal

LB

Toledo

14

Alex Allen

RB

Akron

 

14

Derek McBryde

DB

Kent State

15

EJ Biggers

CB

Western Michigan

 

15

Roger Morris

DT

Ball State

16

Andre Bratton

RB

Miami

 

16

Sam Williams

SS

Central Michigan

17

Cody Cielenski

DL

Western Michigan

 

17

DeAndre DeScott

DB

Akron

18

Adam Antonides

OG

Central Michigan

 

18

Augustus Parrish

DT

Kent State

19

Greg Keys

RB

Kent State

 

19

Lee Renfro

DB

Ohio

20

Aaron Carr

DB

Central Michigan

 

20

John Bonner

WR

Eastern Michigan

21

Robert Brewster

OT

Ball State

 

21

Idris Lawrence

DB

Ohio

22

Dante Love

Ath

Ball State

 

22

Grant Nemeth

DL

Western Michigan

23

Kevin Hobbins

OL

Toledo

 

23

Andre Evans

DB

Buffalo

24

Brad Goatley

LB

Miami

 

24

Mark Metulvnsky

FS

Western Michigan

25

Spencer Farley

RB

Ohio

 

25

Josh Allen

OLB

NIU

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Top 5 JUCOs

 

 

 

 

Top 5 QBs

 

 

 

Top 5 RBs

 

1

Michael Machen

QB

Kent State

 

1

Tim Hiller

Western Michigan

 

1

Dajuane Collins

Toledo

2

Brandon Henderson

CB

Western Michigan

 

2

Sean Price

Central Michigan

 

2

Justin Anderson

NIU

3

DJ Nichols

WR

Toledo

 

3

Brandon Summers

Toledo

 

3

Terrence Blevins

Eastern Michigan

4

RJ Montemayor

TE

Eastern Michigan

 

4

Michael Machen

Kent State

 

4

Alex Allen

Akron

5

Tony Paoli

QB

Buffalo

 

5

Andy Schmitt

Eastern Michigan

 

5

Andre Bratton

Miami

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Top 5 WR/TEs

 

 

 

 

Top 5 OL Prospects

 

 

 

Top 5 DL Prospects

 

1

Orlando Moore

WR

NIU

 

1

Zack Anderson

Akron

 

1

Antwon Hight

Akron

2

EJ Morton-Green

WR

Miami

 

2

Adam Antonides

Central Michigan

 

2

Cody Cielenski

Western Michigan

3

Preston Williams III

WR

NIU

 

3

Robert Brewster

Ball State

 

3

Terricko Marshall

Akron

4

Luke Alexander

WR

Bowling Green

 

4

Kevin Hobbins

Toledo

 

4

Andy Laue

Western Michigan

5

Jose Cruz

TE

Akron

 

5

Matt Bacoulis

Buffalo

 

5

Thomas James

Bowling Green

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Top 5 'Specialists'

 

 

 

 

Top 5 LB Prospects

 

 

 

Top 5 DBs

 

1

Rick Albreski

K/P

Central Michigan

 

1

Phil Brown

NIU

 

1

Melvin Rice

NIU

2

Andy Dittbenner

P

NIU

 

2

Spenser Smith

Eastern Michigan

 

2

EJ Biggers

Western Michigan

3

Jeremy Mack

LS

Toledo

 

3

Brad Goatley

Miami

 

3

Aaron Carr

Central Michigan

4

Dante Love

Ath

Ball State

 

4

Nick Lawrence

Bowling Green

 

4

Jeff Fontana

NIU

5

Reid Macko

PK

Kent State

 

5

Daniel Holtzclaw

Eastern Michigan

 

5

Sean Kavanagh

Miami